Zohran Mamdani wants his city’s most infamous jail shut down for good, and his socialist friends are already calling it justice.

His own corrections boss admits the replacement cells won’t be ready for years.

And Mamdani just tucked one number into his plan that tells you exactly where the overflow is headed.

Zohran Mamdani Finally Put a Date on Emptying Rikers Island

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani rolled out his long-awaited plan to close Rikers Island, the sprawling jail complex that sits in the East River between Queens and the Bronx.

He picked the end of 2032 as his finish line. That lands more than five years after the August 31, 2027 deadline the City Council wrote into law back in 2019.

“I am proud that New York City will close Rikers Island once and for all,” Mamdani told reporters at City Hall.

But the mayor needs the Council to rewrite that 2019 law first, because his administration can’t hit the deadline it inherited. Council Speaker Julie Menin already signaled she’ll play along, blaming “delays under previous administrations.”

And then Mamdani reached for the language of duty. “We have a legal and moral obligation to close Rikers,” he said in a statement.

Legal obligation. From the mayor who just asked to move the legal deadline back five years.

The Blueprints Picked the Number Before the Mayor Did

Here’s the piece of the plan that matters most. Mamdani’s entire strategy depends on cutting the city’s jail population from more than 6,500 people down to roughly 4,500.

Why 4,500? Look at the blueprints. The four replacement jails in Brooklyn, Queens, Manhattan, and the Bronx hold 4,160 beds combined, and city planners tack a few hundred secure hospital beds on top of that. Add them up and you land right around 4,500.

The architects set the ceiling. Now the mayor has to find about 2,000 people who won’t fit under it.

His answer comes in a bundle: new diversion programs, more supervised release, expanded housing and social services, a revived online bail payment system, and faster court calendars. Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards told the City Council his department would “responsibly” shrink the head count, and he floated early release in some cases.

Translation for the retiree who rides the subway home after dark: more accused offenders waiting for trial on the couch instead of behind bars.

Maybe the diversion programs work. Maybe some of those 2,000 really belong in a drug treatment bed instead of a cell. But nobody arrived at 4,500 by studying who’s dangerous. They arrived at it by counting beds.

Mamdani Never Wanted the New Jails in the First Place

The mayor likes to cast himself as the guy who finally follows the law. His own history tells a different story.

In 2019, Mamdani opposed the Council’s closure plan, according to The Marshall Project. He had no problem with shutting Rikers. He objected to building new jails to replace it.

He only came around during his mayoral run, when he pledged to carry out the law already on the books. And his first big personnel move put Richards, a man once locked up on Rikers himself, in charge of the entire Department of Correction.

A neutral manager would sweat the construction schedule and the bed count. Mamdani, a card-carrying member of the Democratic Socialists of America, treats the bed count as a target to shrink, and he’s steering the system toward the smallest footprint he can get away with.

The Guards Are Running Out While the Bill Keeps Climbing

Now look at who has to keep order in the meantime.

Richards told the Council the city’s lockups run at about 92 percent of capacity, which he called “the highest level seen in more than a decade.” His department employs roughly 5,600 uniformed officers, well short of the 7,060 positions the last city budget funded, and a wave of retirements is coming.

Benny Boscio, who leads the union representing 15,000 active and retired correction officers, has called the closure plan “flawed” for exactly this reason. The new jails can’t hold the people the city locks up today.

And the price tag keeps ballooning. The borough jail project started with an estimate around $8 billion and now sits at $15 billion or more. Mamdani also wants $146 million in fresh spending next fiscal year for mental health care, substance-use treatment, job training, and other programs.

The mayor hasn’t explained where all that cash comes from in a city staring at a $7 billion budget gap earlier this year. Taxpayers can probably guess.

New York Already Ran This Experiment Once

The city doesn’t need to wonder how mass releases play out on the street.

New York’s 2019 bail law sent nearly 2,000 defendants out of city jails, and crime climbed 20 percent by mid-March 2020, a New York Post op-ed recently pointed out. A month later, the city let roughly 2,000 more inmates walk out of Rikers over COVID fears.

Mamdani wants to run the same play on purpose, with a bed count as the goal line.

President Trump saw this coming. When Mamdani talked up closing Rikers on the campaign trail, Trump’s verdict fit in three words: “It’s not good.”

But the mayor’s bigger problem has nothing to do with Trump. Every person released under these programs goes home to some neighborhood. Not the gated ones. The working-class blocks in the Bronx, Brooklyn, and Queens, where shop owners already pull the grates down early.

And the federal remediation manager a judge installed at Rikers in January won’t be riding those trains either.

Manhattan Has Closed a Notorious Jail Before

One more detail deserves a spot on the record.

The new Manhattan jail will rise roughly 300 feet over Chinatown, which would make it the tallest jail in the world. A neighborhood group there keeps pushing the mayor to build housing on the lot instead. The mayor who campaigned on affordable housing is keeping the jail.

That lot has a past. The old Manhattan House of Detention, better known as the Tombs, once stood there.

In December 1974, after a federal judge found conditions inside the Tombs unconstitutional, New York City shut it down and shipped the remaining detainees to Rikers Island. Fifty-eight years later, Mamdani plans to shut Rikers down and send them back to the same corner of Manhattan.

Sources: Breitbart News; Associated Press via The Hill and ABC News; CNN; ABC7 New York; The Marshall Project; New York Post; City & State New York; Gothamist; New York City Comptroller’s Office; US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, Rhem v. Malcolm (1975)