The medical examiner stamped Jeffrey Epstein’s jailhouse death a suicide, and the liberal press mocks every doubter to this day.
Seven years of official reviews never quieted the questions.
And one forensic expert just pointed to evidence nobody ever bothered to pick up.
A Brother’s Private Files Did What Seven Years of Official Reviews Wouldn’t
Dr Michael Freeman doesn’t run a podcast or sell T-shirts. He edits the Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, teaches forensic medicine, and served on the Maryland Attorney General’s team that audited dozens of deaths in custody.
And after months with autopsy records and photos that Epstein’s brother, Mark, handed to him and to CBS News, Freeman recently told an audience at Middle Temple, the old London legal society, that the financier more than likely died at someone else’s hands.
“The injuries that were documented by the medical examiner were not consistent with the suicidal hanging. And the injuries that were attributed to something other than potentially a physical struggle or assault were just overlooked,” Freeman told CBS News.
Two other specialists worked alongside him. Anders Eriksson teaches forensic medicine at Umea University in Sweden, and Itiel Dror studies how bias creeps into forensic decisions.
Mark Epstein told CBS the study wasn’t done on his behalf. He has doubted the suicide ruling for years, and in 2020 he hired pathologist Dr Michael Baden, who told 60 Minutes the evidence pointed more toward murder than suicide.
And the New York City medical examiner’s office isn’t budging. “Our office stands by its determination,” a spokesperson said.
Two Marks on the Neck That Shouldn’t Both Be There
Freeman’s case starts with the ligature wounds. The official description fit a classic hanging, with a mark sloping up to a peak. But the photos showed a second mark below the first, running at a different angle.
“There is no mechanism to produce a second mark that would be lower. Even if the ligature was tied with two loops, both loops would go up to the point where it was tied because that’s the anchor point,” Freeman said.
Could Epstein have tried twice? Freeman says that theory needs a false start hard enough to break the hyoid bone and thyroid cartilage, followed by a man who somehow stayed conscious long enough to go again.
“That’s not what suicidal hangings do,” he said.
Then come the injuries a hanging doesn’t explain at all. Freeman points to bleeding deep in the muscle of the left shoulder, blunt force marks on the face, an injury on the back, and what he describes as possible fingernail marks above the ligature line.
“How do you get the deep soft tissue hemorrhage in his left shoulder? How do you get the injury on his back?” he asked.
His 3-D reconstruction, which he built around the account of the guard who found the body, matched some of the neck wounds to a hanging. The rest refused to fit.
The Strip of Orange Cloth Nobody Bagged
Here’s the detail that ought to bother anybody who pays taxes to keep a federal prison system running.
Torn orange bedding cluttered Epstein’s cell. In the photos, Freeman spotted one narrow, knotted strip on the floor. He described it as “a double knotted, looped, narrow ligature that was found in the cell that was dropped in a corner near the desk.”
Freeman says that strip lines up with the ragged, segmented marks on Epstein’s neck. He says the noose investigators carried out doesn’t. “This certainly would not be consistent with the noose that was taken from the room,” he said.
But nobody collected that strip for the medical examiner. It lives in the photographs, and that’s about it.
Sadly, it fits the rest of the scene. Staff hauled the body out within minutes, before investigators could photograph it in place. Nobody sealed the cell. Most of the cameras on the wing didn’t work, and the people reviewing footage from the nearest working camera never chased down an orange blur moving up a staircase toward Epstein’s tier, according to Justice Department documents CBS reviewed.
Corrections officer Michael Thomas, the guard credited with finding Epstein, didn’t sit down with federal investigators until two years later, after prosecutors charged him over falsified records. Those same investigators waited another year before they interviewed the medical examiner.
Every Review Leaned on the Same Unsecured Scene
The Justice Department’s inspector general dug through the case for years and released his report in June 2023. Michael Horowitz found misconduct by 13 Bureau of Prisons employees. Staff transferred Epstein’s cellmate out with nobody to replace him, left extra linens in the cell, and signed off on checks they never made.
But then Horowitz concluded, “we did not uncover evidence contradicting the FBI’s determination there was no criminality in connection with how Epstein died.”
Think about what that sentence rests on. An investigator can only weigh the evidence somebody gathered. If the knotted strip never left the floor, it never entered the file, and no review built on that file could account for it.
That includes the July 2025 memo from the Justice Department and FBI, which released hours of hallway video and called the suicide finding settled. FBI Director Kash Patel and then-Deputy Director Dan Bongino stood behind it. “He killed himself,” Bongino said on Fox News. “I’ve seen the whole file.”
And maybe he had. But a file only holds what a broken prison bureaucracy chose to put in it back in 2019.
The Sneer Brigade Picked the Wrong Target
Mediaite couldn’t write up Freeman’s findings without taking a cheap swipe at Patel and Bongino as men who made their names on conspiracy theories. That’s the newsroom reflex. Ask a question the official story doesn’t like, and the press hangs a label around your neck.
But now the man asking edits a forensic medicine journal and testifies in courtrooms. Good luck calling him a crank.
Freeman admits a journal turned down his paper, and he says the reviewers thought a peer-reviewed publication wasn’t the place to second-guess a medical examiner. He plans to resubmit.
The New York Times ran an investigation in June 2026 that cited Epstein’s own jailhouse notes as signs he meant to end his life. The paper also reported that almost none of the experts it consulted believed the medical evidence alone could settle suicide versus homicide. Forensic pathology isn’t arithmetic.
But that cuts both ways. If the medical evidence can’t settle it, the official ruling doesn’t get the last word either.
Freeman draws his line carefully. He calls the who, the how, and the dead cameras a mystery. “Was this a suicide? Not a mystery,” he said.
House Democrats spent their Epstein energy hunting for any thread that might lead back to Donald Trump, and the Oversight Committee’s final report turned up no documents implicating him. Representative Robert Garcia (D-CA) takes the committee gavel when the new Congress convenes in January. Nobody should hold their breath waiting for him to subpoena a medical examiner over a strip of bedding when there are Trump headlines to chase.
A Closed Jail and an Open Question
The Metropolitan Correctional Center shut its doors in 2021. The guards moved on. The medical examiner’s office stands by its ruling.
So who, exactly, is left to go back for that strip of orange cloth?
Sources: Mediaite, “‘More Than Likely a Homicide’: Forensics Expert Concludes Jeffrey Epstein Did Not Die By Suicide,” November 2026; CBS News, “Jeffrey Epstein’s death may not have been suicide, new analysis by leading forensics expert suggests,” November 2026; Anadolu Agency, “Forensic expert says Epstein’s death more likely homicide than suicide,” November 2026; Turkiye Today, “Expert says Epstein death more likely homicide than suicide,” November 2026; The Week, “‘Jeffrey Epstein was strangled’: Forensic expert says after look at autopsy record,” November 2026; The Daily Beast, “Bombshell Report Raises New Questions About Epstein’s Death,” November 2026; Axios, “DOJ, FBI conclude Epstein had no ‘client list,’ died by suicide,” July 2025; NPR, “Negligence, staff failures led to Jeffrey Epstein’s suicide, DOJ report says,” June 2023; US Department of Justice Office of the Inspector General, press release on the BOP’s custody of Jeffrey Epstein, June 2023; NBC News, “Misconduct and errors allowed Jeffrey Epstein to commit suicide, DOJ finds,” June 2023.

