Barack Obama hit the campaign trail again, and Democrats dusted off their favorite idol for one more victory lap.

Cable hosts gushed that nobody alive could match his star power.

And Donald Trump just handed Stephen A Smith one verdict that left the sports host gasping.

Stephen A Smith Floated a Fantasy Matchup and Got More Than He Bargained For

Stephen A Smith sat down with President Trump at the White House for his Straight Shooter podcast, and the conversation wandered into territory the 22nd Amendment closed off a long time ago.

Smith pitched a hypothetical. If Trump could run for a third term, so could Obama. Who wins?

Trump didn’t blink. “I got many more votes than he got, and I got many more votes in the states,” he said. “And I have most of the state records of the big states. If you take a look at Texas, I have the all-time record. Florida, I have the all-time record.”

Smith asked whether that meant Trump would actually beat Obama.

“Yeah, I think I’d beat him easily,” Trump said.

Smith’s face did the rest of the talking. So Trump doubled down with four words Democrats will be chewing on for weeks: “I think he’s highly overrated.”

“Oh my lord,” Smith shot back, before asking how anybody could call Obama overrated.

Trump kept the explanation short. “I didn’t think he was a good president, I thought he was a divider,” he said. Smith asked how Trump would describe himself. “As a person that brings people together,” the President answered.

Smith later told CNN’s Laura Coates the exchange floored him. “I was shocked that he went that far,” Smith said.

But plenty of Americans who lived through the Obama years won’t find anything shocking about it.

The Vote Counts Back Up Every Word

Trump brought up the numbers, so start there.

Obama’s best night came in 2008, when he pulled in roughly 69.5 million votes. That stood as the all-time record until 2020. Trump collected about 77.3 million votes in 2024, clearing Obama’s high-water mark by nearly 8 million.

The state records check out too. Trump won 6,393,597 votes in Texas in 2024, the first presidential candidate ever to crack 6 million there. Obama managed 3,294,440 in the Lone Star State in 2012. In Florida, Trump’s 6,110,125 votes topped every presidential nominee in decades of state data that Newsweek reviewed.

Obama’s fans will grumble that the country simply has more voters now. But Trump grew his own total from about 62.9 million in 2016 to 77.3 million in 2024. Obama went the other direction, shedding more than 3.5 million votes between his first race and his second.

One of those men built a movement. The other watched his crowd thin out.

The Coattails Democrats Would Rather Not Discuss

Raw votes only cover half the story, though. A party leader also gets graded on what happens to everybody else on the ballot.

And on that test, voters flattened the Democrat Party.

Democrats held 60 Senate seats and 257 House seats when Obama took office in 2009. By the end of his presidency, NPR counted 46 and 188. University of Virginia political scientist Larry Sabato added up the full damage: 11 governorships, 13 US Senate seats, 69 House seats, 913 state legislative seats, and 30 legislative chambers gone on Obama’s watch. Sabato found those losses ran at least double the two-term average from Harry Truman through George W Bush.

Obama practically invited the verdict. Before the 2014 midterms, he told voters his policies were on the ballot, “every single one of them.” Weeks later, Republicans took the Senate.

In 2016, he turned the presidential race into a referendum on his legacy. Hillary Clinton lost anyway.

Democrats still talk about him like a political Midas. The record reads more like a man who could win his own races and nobody else’s.

The Divider Label Has a Paper Trail

Smith acted stunned that anyone would call Obama divisive. Obama’s own mouth makes the case.

Back in 2008, he told a room full of wealthy San Francisco donors that struggling small-town voters “get bitter, they cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who aren’t like them.” A few months into his presidency, he announced that police “acted stupidly” in the arrest of Harvard professor Henry Louis Gates, then needed a beer summit on the White House lawn to mop up the mess.

But the 2010 midterm stretch topped them all. In a Univision radio interview, Obama told Latino listeners, “If Latinos sit out the election instead of saying, ‘We’re gonna punish our enemies, and we’re gonna reward our friends who stand with us on issues that are important to us.’”

Enemies. Those were fellow Americans who disagreed with him on immigration. Obama later conceded he probably should have said “opponents.”

He wasn’t finished. At a Democrat reception that same week, he mocked Republicans who wanted power back. “You can’t have the keys back. You don’t know how to drive!” he cracked.

The public mood followed the rhetoric. The Pew Research Center found 66 percent of Americans calling race relations generally good shortly after Obama’s 2009 inauguration. By May 2015, only 34 percent felt that way, and 61 percent called them generally bad.

Maybe some of that slide would’ve happened under any President. But a man who sold himself as the great healer and then branded his critics enemies doesn’t get to wave off the scoreboard.

The Comeback Tour Had a Silent Partner

Now Democrats want to credit Obama with a midterm resurrection. He stumped for Sherrod Brown in Ohio and Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan, and both men won Senate races.

The press calls it proof the old magic still works.

Look a little closer. Voters had plenty on their minds besides a former President’s charm. In the NBC News exit poll, 63 percent of voters said the decision to take military action against Iran was the wrong one. The neoconservatives who pushed for that war handed Democrats an issue on a silver platter, and Obama showed up in time to collect the applause.

And the winners he helped aren’t exactly bridge-builders. El-Sayed ran on Medicare for All and the rest of the socialist wish list, and he still dodges straight answers about where Sharia fits in his personal obligations. That’s the brand of Democrat politics Obama blessed.

Expect the party to wheel Obama out again in 2028 as its unifier-in-chief. The speeches will sound lovely. The track record tells a different story.

Trump, for his part, closed the interview with some friendly advice for Smith about ever running for office himself. “I would keep your life the way it is. You know what? You’ll find it very nasty if you do,” the President said.

Obama could have told him that much. In late October 2010, he urged Latino voters to punish their enemies. A week later, voters took 63 House seats away from his party.

Sources: Fox News; Newsweek; IBTimes UK; Mediaite; The Daily Beast; NPR; Washington Times (Larry Sabato, UVA Center for Politics); PolitiFact; Quorum; CBS News; TheBlaze; Christian Century/ABP; Pew Research Center; KTVU/Fox Television Stations; NBC News exit poll.