Ilhan Omar built a career on a tearjerker refugee story, and Democrats brand anyone who doubts it a bigot.
Her harshest new critics don’t fit that label very well.
And one Somali historian just learned the price of digging into her family.
An Oxford-Trained Scholar Lost His Award Before He Ever Boarded the Plane
Mohamed Haji Ingiriis doesn’t write for some right-wing website. He was born in Somalia, earned a PhD in African history from the University of Oxford, and works as a fellow at King’s College London.
He also knows more about the late father of Representative Ilhan Omar (D-MN) than almost anyone alive.
And that knowledge may have cost him a trophy.
The organizers of the Somali Hero Awards had lined Ingiriis up to receive an honor for his scholarship at a ceremony in Minneapolis on November 14. Then, according to Ingiriis, they called the whole thing off at the last minute.
Ingiriis told the Daily Caller News Foundation that the organizers revoked his airline ticket and pulled his award. He says they told him that any Somali who has criticized the congresswoman can’t safely travel to Minneapolis. Facebook posts that somebody later deleted, but that Google had already indexed, point to his appearance getting scrapped.
Ali Gaashaan, president of the Somali Hero Awards, tells a different story. He texted the DCNF that he “has never heard threats of violence against any critic” of Omar.
But Gaashaan never answered the one question that matters. When the DCNF asked why his group canceled Ingiriis’ appearance, he went silent. He did find time to accuse Alpha News and the DCNF of pushing “an extreme right-wing agenda.”
Omar’s office ignored detailed questions about the canceled award, the historian’s research, and the reports of threats.
The Colonel at the Center of the Whole Mess
Ingiriis studies the military dictatorship of Siad Barre, the strongman who ran Somalia until his government collapsed in 1991.
According to his research, Omar’s father went by Nur Said Elmi and held the rank of colonel. Ingiriis says the colonel ran the military training school in the southern city of Baidoa and earlier commanded a brigade in Garbahaarrey, Barre’s own hometown. Plenty of senior officers deserted as rebel clans closed in on the capital. Ingiriis says Omar’s father stayed loyal to the bitter end.
The historian draws a careful line here. He says no evidence puts the colonel at the scene of Barre’s slaughter of the Isaaq clan in the north, and nothing ties him to war crimes. But he argues the refugee claim itself never held water. “It is not legitimate because he was an ambassador of the military regime that caused this,” Ingiriis said.
Saeed Ibrahim, editor-in-chief of the Somaliland Chronicle, put the rank in plain terms. “You don’t get to that level and that rank with that sort of a regime by being the nice guy,” he said.
The colonel died of COVID-19 complications in 2020 and can’t answer for himself. Omar faces no charges over any of this, and she has dismissed the investigations into her family as political attacks. Newsmax reported that the federal probe started inside the Human Rights Violations and War Crimes Unit of Homeland Security Investigations. DHS declined to comment.
Democrats Keep Speaking for a Community That Won’t Stay Quiet
Democrats and their media pals love to treat “the Somali community” like a single voting bloc with Ilhan Omar as its official spokeswoman. Ask her a hard question, and somebody yells racism before the reporter finishes the sentence.
That cartoon never matched reality.
Somali voices raised many of the earliest questions about Omar’s background. A Somali man named Abdi Nur told the conservative Power Line blog that after he spoke up, he faced veiled threats, fake complaints meant to shut down his Facebook page, and online abuse mocking him for using a wheelchair. Alpha News republished his account.
In October, Power Line’s Scott Johnson wrote that Somali friends had called him in distress over threats coming out of Europe and aimed at perceived Omar opponents in the Twin Cities. The Hot Air writer who passed the report along admitted he couldn’t vouch for the callers himself.
And back in July 2022, a crowd at a Somali Week concert at the Target Center booed Omar when she walked onstage to hand out an award. Some of them yelled at her to get out.
A community marching in lockstep behind its congresswoman doesn’t boo her off a stage. The fault lines look an awful lot like the clan and political divisions that tore Somalia apart in the first place.
The Old Country’s Feuds Moved Into a Minneapolis Zip Code
Here’s the part Democrats never want to touch. When Washington resettles huge numbers of people from a war zone in a short stretch of time, it doesn’t just bring in families. It imports the grudges, the loyalties, and the clan rivalries that started the war.
Assimilation should wash those feuds out over time. But assimilation needs patience and modest numbers, and federal resettlement offered neither. Minneapolis alone now counts more than 80,000 Somali residents, according to coverage of the December 2025 Somali Hero Awards.
So an Oxford-trained scholar, by his own account, gets told he can’t safely pick up an award in an American city because of what he wrote about a dead colonel. That kind of thing happens in Mogadishu. Most Minnesotans would never expect it in their own backyard.
Maybe the organizers simply got cold feet over bad press. Gaashaan insists he never heard a single threat. But a nonprofit that yanks a plane ticket from its own honoree owes somebody an explanation, and so far it hasn’t offered one.
The double standard stings too. Omar talks often about the threats she receives, and a Florida man pleaded guilty to threatening to kill her and her children. Nobody should shrug at that. Yet the same press corps that chronicles every threat against Omar has shown zero curiosity about a Somali historian who says he got warned away from her district.
Omar Still Echoes the Dictator’s Favorite Dream
Barre built his rule partly on the dream of a “Greater Somalia,” a single nation stretching past colonial borders into slices of Kenya, Ethiopia, and Djibouti. His regime called those regions “occupied territories.” When Somaliland pushed to break away, Barre’s forces crushed the Isaaq clan, and some estimates put the dead as high as 200,000.
Omar opposes independence for Somaliland too.
“Somalia is one. We are brothers and sisters, and our land will not be balkanized,” she said in the Somali language at a 2024 event in Minnesota, according to the translation Omar herself called the most accurate. She kept going. “Our lands were taken from us before, and God willing, we may one day seek them, but what we have now will not be balkanized.”
A sitting member of the US Congress musing about someday reclaiming “taken” lands for a foreign country ought to raise eyebrows on both sides of the aisle. It barely raised one.
And she said it to a hometown crowd, in a language most of her constituents can’t understand.
Washington Helped Train Barre’s Officers Before It Let Them In
One more wrinkle makes this story even messier. The Reagan administration courted Barre after he broke with his Soviet patrons, and the Pentagon trained more than 300 of his officers at Fort Leavenworth in the 1980s. Ingiriis believes that history helps explain why some of Barre’s men later settled comfortably in the West without many questions.
The vetting bureaucracy of the 1990s deserves its share of blame. It waved in refugees by the planeload and accepted paperwork from a collapsed country at face value.
House Democrats take the gavels in January. Expect the Oversight Committee to treat the war crimes unit’s interest in the Omar family as one more act of persecution and to drag DHS officials in front of the cameras to defend themselves.
But no subpoena will change the colonel’s rank, or what a Somali historian says happened when he tried to collect his award.
Mohamed Haji Ingiriis can lecture in London and publish his findings anywhere in the free world. Nobody has explained yet why the one place he apparently can’t go to collect an award for that work sits inside Ilhan Omar’s district.
Sources: Daily Caller News Foundation (Emily Kopp), “SCOOP: Historian Researching Ilhan Omar’s Colonel Father Warned To Avoid Minneapolis Over Clan Violence”; Hot Air (David Strom), “Did Ilhan Omar Send a Veiled Threat to Her Somali Constituents?”; Alpha News, “A Message From Abdi Nur”; Washington Free Beacon and The Washington Times, coverage of Omar booed at Somali Week concert, July 2022; WUSF and Minnesota Star Tribune, coverage of guilty plea in threats against Omar; CT Somali, “Somali Hero Awards Bring Together Community Leaders and Cultural Figures in Minnesota”

